REVIEW: “The Penitent” by M.J. Klimmek

Review of M.J. Klimmek, “The Penitent,” Luna Station Quarterly 63 (September 2025): 293-321 — Purchase here. Reviewed by Sara L. Uckelman.

The nameless narrator has been in exile on her island for more than four years, punishment for having killed fellow members of her Order. With a Guardian patrolling the island and a mark on her forehead shutting her away from her magic and telling anyone she met — not that there’s anyone else on the island — that she’s a traitor, there is no escape. But there is penitence, and watching the way it manifests in this story was intriguing. I’m not quite sure I agree with all the decisions the penitent made, but I can see how they could make sense.